Hi,

I don't understand why I have a difference between my output

(diatonic-chord 
 '(:f Imaj7 ii7) 
 :inv '(0 0))

=>(f4a4c5e5 g4bb4d5f4)

and my snippet which displays a different voicing with f on basse of the second chord.

 

Thank you for your help.

There is no difference, this is only because the notes are not sorte up in the second chord but you have a f4 in the second chord, so you get it on snippet display. No problem here.

I expressed myself badly. I want the chords in the root state so the second should be => (f4a4c5e5 g4bb4d5f5)

I'm not a specialist of that function, I never use it but I think it apply internally closest-path function to the progression.

 

 

there is a difference between the listener and the Snippet, it's not very logical...I would like to understand

As Stephane said there is no difference. The F4 is the lowest note.

The chord is not sorted. 

g4bb4d5f4

 

Jesper

how to make it so?

It doesn't matter if they get sorted, The F4 needs to be an F5.

I don't know if that's possible within the function.

 

Jesper

 

 

arguments are used for this ? :inv '(0 0))

here is the answer!

(diatonic-chord 
 '(:f Imaj7 ii7) 
  :inv '(0 1) :sort t)